Sarge's Deli Catering and the Holidays Online Ordering Menu

548 Third Ave
New York, NY 10016

10:00 AM - 10:00 PM

100% of 22 customers recommended

Start your carryout or delivery order.

Check Availability

ROSH HASHANAH - TRADITIONAL HOLIDAY SPECIALTIES

For your convenience all food is packaged COLD and arrives COLD in microwavable or oven ready containers for easy heating prior to serving.

Homemade Chicken Consommé

Mushroom & Barley Soup

Split Pea Soup (Extra Thick)

Homemade Kreplach

Matzo Balls “Nobody does it better!”

Matzo Ball Soup for 2

Kreplach Soup for 2

Chopped Chicken Liver

Fresh Roast Brisket of Beef

Freshly Grated Horseradish (red or white)

Sweet Potato Tzimmes (Outrageously Delicious)

Creamy Mashed Potatoes

Creamed Spinach

Stuffed Cabbage

Holiday Stuffing (Awesome!)

Kasha Varnishkas (None Better)

Egg Barley with Mushrooms

Homemade Giblet Gravy

Sliced Roasted Turkey (White, Dark, Mixed)

String Beans Almondine

Whole Roast Chicken

Swedish Meatballs (25)

Norwegian Salmon Filet

BREAK THE FAST!

The very finest smoked fish and appetizers.

Nova Scotia Salmon

Large Lake Sturgeon

Belly Lox (Salty)

Baked Kippered Salmon

Jumbo Whitefish

Whole Decorated Jumbo Whitefish Filet

Whole Decorated Jumbo Stuffed Whitefish

Pickled Herring in Cream Sauce

Maatjes Herring Filets in Wine Sauce

Pickled Herring Filets

Smoked Whitefish Salad

Chopped Herring

Baked Salmon Salad

Cucumber Vinaigrette

Plain Cream Cheese

Scallion Cream Cheese

Vegetable Cream Cheese

Assorted Bagels

#1 Smoked Salmon Buffet

10 person minimum. Includes: Nova Scotia Salmon; Assorted Bagels; Scallion, Plain, and Veggie Cream Cheese; and A Platter of Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, and Black & Green Olives.

#2 Deluxe Smoked Fish Buffet

10 person minimum. Includes any of the following: Stuffed White Fish, Nova Scotia Salmon, Baked Kippered Salmon, Sable, or Sturgeon; Assorted Bagels; Scallion, Plain, and Veggie Cream Cheese; and A Platter of Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, and Black & Green Olives.

#3 Assorted Salad Buffet

10 person minimum. Includes a choice of any 3 Salads: Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Baked Salmon Salad (+$2 per person), or Whitefish Salad (+$2 per person); Lettuce and Sliced Tomato; Assorted Bagels, and Scallion, Plain, and Veggie Cream Cheese.

Assorted Cheese Platter

3 lbs. of Sliced Cheese on a Tray.

ROSH HASHANAH - DELICIOUS HOLIDAY DESSERTS

Sarge’s Legendary Cheesecake

Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake

Marble Nut Halvah

Homemade Ruggelach

Chocolate Babka

SANDWICHES, BAGELS, & MEAT PLATTERS

Sandwich Platter (5 Serving Minimum)

Assorted Sandwiches on Rye displayed on a Decorative Platter, Cut in Thirds. (Pick up to 5 items) Choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami, Roast Beef, Fresh Roast Turkey, Kosher Beef, Salami, Tongue, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad, Grilled Veggie Wraps. Includes: Decorated Bowl of Potato Salad, Cole Slaw and a Bowl of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives. Mustard, Mayonnaise and Russian Dressing.

Cold Cut Buffet (5 Serving Minimum)

Includes Choice of 5 meats on a Decorated Platter, (Pick up to 5 items) Choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami, Fresh Roast Turkey, Kosher Beef, Salami and Tongue. Bowl of Homemade Cole Slaw, Potato Salad and a Bowl of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives. Mustard, Mayonnaise and Russian Dressing.

Roll-A-Rama (5 Serving Minimum)

Tray of Assorted Sandwiches on Our Luncheon Size Vienna Rolls. (Pick up to 5 items) Choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami, Fresh Roast Turkey, Kosher Beef Salami, Tongue Includes: Decorated Bowl of Potato Salad, Cole Slaw and a Bowl of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives, Mustard, Mayonnaise and Russian Dressing.

Assorted Salad & Bagel Buffet (5 Serving Minimum)

Decorated Bowls of Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad along side a Platter of Lettuce and Sliced Tomato and Assorted Sliced Fresh Bagels.

Assorted Deluxe Salad & Bagel Buffet (5 Serving Minimum)

Decorated Bowls of Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad, Baked Salmon Salad, Whitefish Salad and Shrimp Salad along side a Platter of Lettuce and Sliced Tomato and Assorted Sliced Fresh Bagels.

Assorted Bagel Platter with Cream Cheese and Butter (10 Serving Minimum)

Includes Assorted Sliced Fresh Bagels, Plain, Vegetable, Scallion Cream Cheese and Butter.

SMOKED FISH

Smoked Salmon Package (10 Serving Minimum)

Includes: An Elegant Display of Freshly Hand-Sliced Smoked Salmon, Beautifully Placed on a Platter with Plain, Scallion and Vegetable Cream Cheese, Bermuda Onion, Tomatoes, Black and Green Olives. Accompanied By a Tray of Assorted Sliced Bagels (1.5 Bagels Per Person)

Deluxe Smoked Fish Buffet (10 Serving Minimum)

Assortment of Fish on a Beautifully Decorated Tray. Choice of Large Stuffed Smoked Whitefish, Nova Scotia Salmon, Sturgeon, Baked (Kippered) Salmon and Sliced Smoked Sable. Includes Sliced Fresh Assorted Bagels and Bialys, Plain, Scallion, Vegetable Cream Cheese and Butter, 2 lb. Bowl of Herring in Cream Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, Bermuda Onion, Lemon Wedges, Black and Green Olives.

FRESH SALADS

Chopped Salad (Feeds 15)

Iceberg Romaine, Radicchio, Cucumber, Tomato, Green Onions, Chick Peas and Roasted Corn.

Tossed Green Salad (Serves 15)

Romaine and Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Carrots and Spring Mix.

Caesar Salad (Serves 15)

Romaine Lettuce, Croutons, Grated Parmigiana and Creamy Caesar Dressing.

Greek Salad (Serves 15)

Grape Leaves, Feta Cheese, Black Olives and Anchovies on a Bed of Mixed Greens in Our Mediterranean Dressing.

Pasta Primavera (Serves 15)

Fusilli Pasta, Broccoli, Peas and Carrots Mixed in a House Dressing.

Cobb Salad (Serves 15)

Grilled Chicken Breast, Avocado, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Bacon, Sliced Egg and Tomato on Mixed Greens.

HOT HORS D'OEUVRES

Swedish Meatballs (25)

Miniature Potato Pancakes with Apple Sauce (25 pieces per order)

HOT ENTREES

Roast Chicken (5 Serving Minimum)

Each serving consists of a Half Chicken Quartered.

Brisket with Gravy (5 Serving Minimum)

Chicken Parmigiana (5 Serving Minimum)

Complete Turkey Dinner (Serves 5)

Sliced Fresh Turkey, With Stuffing, Giblet Gravy and Choice of Potato & Vegetable.

Corned Beef & Cabbage with Boiled Potato (Serves 5)

TRADITIONAL SPECIALTIES & SIDES

Kasha Varnishkas

Egg Barley & Mushrooms

Mashed Potatoes

Homemade Stuffing

Roasted Potatoes

Slow-Cooked Baked Beans

Creamed Spinach

DESSERTS

Seasonal Fruit Bowl

Assorted Ruggelach Platter (3 lbs)

Chocolate, Raspberry, Cinnamon & Apricot.

Black & White Platter

12 Large Black & White Cookies Cut in Half.

Marble Nut Halvah Platter (3 Pounds)

Apple Strudel Log

Plain New York Legendary Cheese Cake (10")

Plain New York Legendary Cheese Cake topped with Fresh Strawberries

BIG GAME MENU - SUCCULENT BIG GAME WINGS

Herd of Buffalo

BIG GAME MENU - CLASSIC PREGAME FAVORITES

Sarge's Slammin Sliders

Hot Dogs with Fixings

BIG GAME MENU - MOUNTAINS OF MEAT BY THE POUND

House Cured Corned Beef

House Cured Pastrami

Sarge's Famous Thinly Sliced Brisket

BIG GAME MENU - SALADS BY THE POUND

BIG GAME MENU - HEROS & SANDWICHES

Includes Homemade Cole Slaw and Potato Salad.

Cold Cut Buffet Sandwich

BREAKFAST CATERING

10 Person Minimum.

Smoked Salmon Package

Includes: An Elegant Display of Freshly Hand-Sliced Smoked Salmon, Beautifully Placed on a Platter with Plain, Scallion and Vegetable Cream Cheese, Bermuda Onion, Tomatoes, Black and Green Olives. Accompanied By a Tray of Assorted Bagels, Choice of Orange, Tomato or Apple Juice and A Box of Coffee,Tea or Hot Chocolate.

Deluxe Smoked Fish Buffet

Assortment of Fish on a Beautifully Decorated Tray. Choice of Large Stuffed Smoked Whitefish, Nova Scotia Salmon, Sturgeon, Baked (Kippered) Salmon and Sliced Smoked Sable. Includes Fresh Assorted Bagels and Bialys, Plain, Scallion, Vegetable Cream Cheese and Butter, 2 lb. Bowl of Herring in Cream Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, Bermuda Onion, Lemon Wedges, Black and Green Olives.

Seasonal Fruit Bowl

Deluxe Selection of Golden Pineapple, Honeydew, Cantaloupe, Seedless Grapes and Mixed Berries.

Assorted Bagel Platter

An Assortment of Bagels and Bialys Accompanied by Plain, Scallion, Vegetable Cream Cheese and Butter.

Assorted Fresh Juices

Choice of Apple, Orange, Tomato, Grapefruit or Cranberry.

Hot Beverage Service

Serves 10. Our Freshly Ground Colombian House Blend Coffee, Fresh Decaffeinated Coffee, Hot Lipton Tea, Flavored Herbal Tea or Hot Chocolate.

PARTY & OFFICE MEETING FAVORITES

Choose from our Sandwich party, Cold Cut Buffet or Roll-A-Rama.

Junior Sandwich Party

5 Person Minimum. Assorted 4 oz. Sandwiches on a Decorative Party Platter- Cut in Thirds, Choice of Sandwich or Wrap. Includes Decorated Bowl of Potato Salad, A Bowl of Coleslaw, Relish Tray of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives, Mustard, Mayonnaise and Russian Dressing.

Cold Cut Buffet

5 Persons Minimum. Includes Choice of 5 meats on a Decorated Platter, (Pick up to 5 items) Choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami, Roast Beef,Fresh Roast Turkey, Kosher Beef Salami and Tongue. Bowl of Homemade Cole Slaw, Potato Salad and a Bowl of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives.Mustard, Mayonnaise and Russian Dressing.

Classic Sandwich Party

5 Persons Minimum. Assorted Sandwiches on your choice of bread (Rye Bread is Suggested) displayed on a Decorative Platter, Cut in Thirds. Wraps are cut in half) (Pick up to 5 items) Choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami, Roast Beef,Fresh Roast Turkey,Kosher Beef Salami,Tongue,Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad, Grilled Veggie Wraps. Includes: Decorated Bowl of Potato Salad, Cole Slaw and a Bowl of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives. Mustard, Mayonnaise and Russian Dressing.

5 Persons Minimum. Tray of Assorted Sandwiches on Our Luncheon Size Vienna Rolls. (Pick up to 5 items) Choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami, Roast Beef,Fresh Roast Turkey,Kosher Beef Salami,Tongue,Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad Includes: Decorated Bowl of Potato Salad, Cole Slaw and a Bowl of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives, Mustard, Mayonnaise and Russian Dressing.

ADDITIONAL PARTY & OFFICE MEETING FAVORITES

Assorted Salad Buffet Selections.

Assorted Cheese Platter

3 lbs. of Sliced Cheese on a Tray. Choice of American, Swiss, Muenster, Cheddar, Provolone and Mozzarella.

Assorted Salad Buffet

10 person minimum. Decorated Bowls of Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad along side a Platter of Lettuce and Sliced Tomato, Rye Bread and Dinner Rolls.

Assorted Salad Buffet

10 person minimum. Pick Any 3 of 6: Decorated Bowls of Baked Salmon Salad, Whitefish Salad, Shrimp Salad, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad along side a Platter of Lettuce and Sliced Tomato, Rye Bread and Dinner Rolls.

HOT DOG CORNER

On the Side: Sauerkraut, Sarge's Onion Sauce, Relish, Mustard & Ketchup.

Hot Dogs with the Fixings (1 Dozen)

On the Side: Sauerkraut, Sarge's Onion Sauce, Relish, Mustard & Ketchup Add on Potato and Coleslaw, Chili and Cheese, Pastrami and Pickles.

ASSORTED COLD UPTOWN SALADS

Large Tray Feeds 18-23 People. Medium Tray Feeds 12-17 People. Small Bowl Feeds 7-11 People.

Tossed Green Salad

Romaine and Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Carrots and Spring Mix.

Romaine Lettuce, Croutons, Grated Parmigiana and Creamy Caesar Dressing.

Iceberg Romaine, Radicchio, Cucumber, Tomato, Green Onions, Chick Peas and Roasted Corn.

Grape Leaves, Feta Cheese, Black Olives and Anchovies on a Bed of Mixed Greens in Our Mediterranean Dressing.

Pasta Primavera

Fusilli Pasta, Broccoli, Peas and Carrots Mixed in a House Dressing.

Grilled Vegetables

Eggplant, Zucchini, Peppers, Onion and Mushrooms in House Dressing.

Grilled Chicken Breast, Avocado, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Bacon, Sliced Egg and Tomato on Mixed Greens.

SARGE TRADITIONAL SPECIALTIES

Kasha Varnishkas

Large Tray Feeds 12-15 People. Small Tray Feeds 5-8 People.

Large Tray Feeds 12-15 People. Small Tray Feeds 5-8 People.

Egg Barley & Mushrooms

Large Tray Feeds 12-15 People. Small Tray Feeds 5-8 People.

Cheese Blintzes

2 Pieces with Apple Sauce and Sour Cream. 5 Persons Minimum.

3 Pieces, Fried or Broiled. Served with Sour Cream and Sauteed Onions. 5 Persons Minimum.

Stuffed Cabbage

1 Piece. 5 Persons Minimum.

Corned Beef & Cabbage

With Boiled Potato. 5 Persons Minimum.

Brisket with Gravy

5 Persons Minimum.

Half Chicken Per Person. 5 Persons Minimum.

CONTINENTAL FAVORITES

5 Person Minimum.

Chicken Parmigiana

SOUPS BY THE QUART

Chicken Consommé (1 qt.)

Homemade Kreplach (1)

Large Matzo Ball (1)

Split Pea Soup (1 qt.)

Mushroom Barley Soup (1 qt.)

Vegetable Soup (1 qt.)

BY THE POUND

1 lb. Potato Salad

1 lb. Macaroni Salad

1 lb. Cucumber Salad

1 lb. Plain Cream Cheese

1 lb. Scallion Cream Cheese

1 lb. Vegetable Cream Cheese

1 lb. Tuna Salad

1 lb. Chicken Salad

1 lb. Egg Salad

1 lb. Shrimp Salad

1 lb. Herring in Onions & Cream Sauce

Herring Fillet (Per Piece)

1 lb. Chopped Herring

1 lb. Whitefish Salad

1 lb. Baked Salmon Salad

1 lb. Chopped Chicken Liver

1 lb. Turkey Pastrami

1 lb. Hard Salami

1 lb. Boiled Ham

1 lb. Liverwurst

1 lb. Beef Salami

1 lb. Beef Bologna

1 lb. Baked Virginia Ham

1 lb. American Cheese

1 lb. Swiss Cheese

1 lb. Cheddar Cheese

1 lb. Muenster Cheese

1 lb. Mozzarella Cheese

1 lb. Provolone Cheese

1 lb. Nova Scotia Salmon

1 lb. Belly Lox

1 lb. Baked Kippered Salmon

1 lb. Smoked Sable

1 lb. Large Lake Sturgeon

1 lb. Smoked Whitefish

1 lb. Corned Beef

1 lb. Brisket of Beef

1 lb. Roast Beef

1 lb. Rolled Beef

Our Special Burger Blend

Vacuum packaged (frozen) 4-pack of 8 oz. burgers.

1 lb. Beef Franks

1 lb. Knockwurst

1 lb. Matzoh Ball

COLD HORS D'OEUVRES & FRUIT PLATTERS

Colossal Gulf Shrimp Cocktail Platter

15 Piece Minimum. Served on a Decorated Platter with Cocktail Sauce and Lemon Wedges.

Chopped Chicken Liver Mold

Served with Cocktail bread. Large Tray Feed 12-15 People. Small Tray Feeds 5-8 People.

Crudites (Seasonal Fresh Vegetable Platter) with Fresh Garden Vegetable Dip

Choose from Small, Medium or Large Platter. Large Tray Feeds 30-35 People. Medium Tray Feeds 20-25 People. Small Tray Feeds 12-15 People.

Assorted Cheese Platter

Small Cubes of Cheese with Bread Sticks and Crackers. Large Tray Feeds 30-35 People. Medium Tray Feeds 20-25 People. Small Tray Feeds 12-15 People.

Assorted Fruit & Cheese Platter

With Bread Sticks and Crackers. Large Tray Feeds 30-35 People. Medium Tray Feeds 20-25 People. Small Tray Feeds 12-15 People.

Assorted Fresh Fruit Platter

Large Tray Feeds 30-35 People. Medium Tray Feeds 20-25 People. Small Tray Feeds 12-15 People.

HOT HORS D'OEUVRES

25 Pieces Per Tray.

Franks in a Blanket (25)

Miniature Potato Knishes (25)

Swedish Meatballs in Sweet & Sour Sauce (25)

Mom's Turn of the Century Recipe.

Mozzarella Sticks (25)

Served with Marinara Sauce.

Miniature Potato Pancakes AKA Latke

Served with Apple Sauce.

Miniature Spinach & Feta Puffs (25)

Chicken Tenders (25)

10 Piece Minimum.

Fried Fantail Shrimp

10 Pierce Minimum. Beautifully Butterflied Colossal Gulf Shrimp fried to perfection in our own century old batter recipe (Sweet & Sour Sauce).

FABULOUS BUFFALO WINGS

Served with blue cheese dressing and celery.

Herd of Buffalo

FOUR & SIX FOOT HERO BUFFET

Everything You Need For 20-25 Hungry People. Requires 24 Hour Notice. All Hero Buffet Includes A Bowl of Our Homemade Potato Salad, A Bowl of Our Homemade Creamy Coleslaw, Relish Tray of Assorted Pickles, Peppers, Tomatoes and Olives, Mustard, Russian Dressing and Mayonnaise.

1. The New Yorker

Traditional New York Deli Style Corned Beef Pastrami, Fresh Sliced Turkey, Roast Beef and Kosher Salami. Topped with Coleslaw and Russian Dressing.

2. The Mulberry Street Hero Buffet

Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Ham, Capicola, Provolone, Sliced Tomatoes and Lettuce, Topped with Red Pimentos, Oil and Vinegar.

3. The All American Hero Buffet

Prime Roast Beef, Fresh Roast Turkey, Boiled Ham and Swiss Cheese with Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes.

SARGE'S HOMEMADE CHEESE CAKES

Plain New York Legendary Cheese Cake

Fresh Strawberry Cheese Cake

Peanut Butter Chocolate Cheese Cake

Oreo Cheese Cake

KIDS CORNER

Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

(5 person minimum.) Grilled American on white toast. Cut in half, served in trays.

(5 person minimum). Ketchup served on the side.

(5 person minimum). Mustard, ketchup, and sauerkraut on the side.

Sarge's Famous Crinkle Cut French Fries

Slow-Cooked Baked Beans

SARGE'S SIDES

Large Trays Feed 15-18 People. Small Trays Feed 5-8 People.

Mashed Potatoes

Roasted Potatoes

Creamed Spinach

Slow-Cooked Baked Beans

Crinkle Cut French Fries

Corn on the Cob

Homemade Stuffing

Homemade Creamy Coleslaw

Homemade Potato Salad

Homemade Macaroni Salad

String Beans Almondine

EXTRAS

Small Pickles (1 qt.)

Large Pickles (Per Piece)

DESSERTS

Large Black & White Cookies

Large Chocolate Chip Cookies

All Butter Pound Cake

Marble Nut Halvah (1/2 lb.)

Chocolate Eclair

Apple Strudel Log

Apple Crumb Pie

Cherry Crumb Pie

Blueberry Crumb Pie

Lemon Meringue Pie

Banana Cream Pie

Chocolate Cream Pie

Seven Layer Cake

Chocolate Mousse Cake

Strawberry Short Cake

German Chocolate Cake

Red Velvet Cake

Chocolate Fudge Cake

1 Dozen Brownies & Blondies

1 lb. Homemade Ruggelach

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie (Box of 10)

Individual Serve.

BEVERAGES

Gus Grown Up Soda

100% Natural, Crisp, Clean, Craft, Not Too Sweet, Real Juice and Cane Sugar.

Single Serve. Sparking Natural Mineral Water.

Sugar Free Red Bull

Your cart is empty.

Accepts Google Pay

Accepts Venmo